Steam Engine/Spec Metric - Revision history

Syk0 saje at 12:09, 28 May 2011

2011-05-28T12:09:56Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:09, 28 May 2011
Line 1:		Line 1:
	=Calculation of a Metric Score=		= Calculation of a Metric Score =

	Following questions are drawn from [[OSE Specifications]] and is used to determine how well the Steam Engine product meets OSE specs. There are no real guidelines on how to use these questions. Given that there are 42 questions and a max score of 42, we assume that each question is awarded one point. In those cases where partial results are present, a score of 0.5 is awarded, leading to the possible metric score as a decimal number.		Following questions are drawn from [[OSE Specifications]] and is used to determine how well the Steam Engine product meets OSE specs. There are no real guidelines on how to use these questions. Given that there are 42 questions and a max score of 42, we assume that each question is awarded one point. In those cases where partial results are present, a score of 0.5 is awarded, leading to the possible metric score as a decimal number.
Line 335:		Line 335:
	\|-		\|-
	\|}		\|}

			[[Category: Steam Engine]]

Gregortheinventor: /* Economic Feasibility and Replicability */

2011-05-19T20:55:29Z

Economic Feasibility and Replicability

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:55, 19 May 2011
Line 83:		Line 83:

	23. Is there minimal waste?<br>		23. Is there minimal waste?<br>
	.5pt - ''~~By itself, the~~ steam ~~engine~~ is ~~wasteful - steam is vented as waste. Later~~, ~~this could be re-used~~ in ~~other systems~~.''		.5pt - ''The steam is recondensed and can be recycled, but some maintenance need in anticipated, which will produce small amounts of waste.''

	24. Are R&D costs shared by a number of stakeholders?<br>		24. Are R&D costs shared by a number of stakeholders?<br>

Mjn: /* Calculation of a Metric Score */

2011-05-19T18:39:12Z

Calculation of a Metric Score

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:39, 19 May 2011
Line 2:		Line 2:

	Following questions are drawn from [[OSE Specifications]] and is used to determine how well the Steam Engine product meets OSE specs. There are no real guidelines on how to use these questions. Given that there are 42 questions and a max score of 42, we assume that each question is awarded one point. In those cases where partial results are present, a score of 0.5 is awarded, leading to the possible metric score as a decimal number.		Following questions are drawn from [[OSE Specifications]] and is used to determine how well the Steam Engine product meets OSE specs. There are no real guidelines on how to use these questions. Given that there are 42 questions and a max score of 42, we assume that each question is awarded one point. In those cases where partial results are present, a score of 0.5 is awarded, leading to the possible metric score as a decimal number.

			'''Current score''' (see last section) is 21.5 out of 42 pts.

	==Economic Significance==		==Economic Significance==

Mjn: /* Metric Roll-up and Score */

2011-05-19T18:38:26Z

Metric Roll-up and Score

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:38, 19 May 2011
Line 329:		Line 329:
	\|-		\|-
	\|		\|
	!Total Score		\|'''Total Score'''
	\|21.5		\|21.5
	\|-		\|-
	\|}		\|}

Mjn: /* Metric Roll-up and Score */

2011-05-19T18:37:52Z

Metric Roll-up and Score

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:37, 19 May 2011
Line 327:		Line 327:
	\|Training		\|Training
	\|0		\|0
			\|-
			\|
			!Total Score
			\|21.5
	\|-		\|-
	\|}		\|}

Mjn: /* Metric Roll-up and Score */

2011-05-19T18:34:03Z

Metric Roll-up and Score

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:34, 19 May 2011
Line 154:		Line 154:
	=Metric Roll-up and Score=		=Metric Roll-up and Score=

	{\|		{\| border="1"
	\|-		\|-
	!No.		!No.
Line 297:		Line 297:
	\|-		\|-
	\|35.		\|35.
	\|		\|CAD Drawings
	\|??		\|0
	\|-		\|-
	\|36.		\|36.

Mjn: /* Metric Roll-up and Score */

2011-05-19T18:33:08Z

Metric Roll-up and Score

Show changes

Mjn: /* Designs */

2011-05-19T18:14:43Z

Designs

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:14, 19 May 2011
Line 132:		Line 132:

	37. Is ecoDnomic analysis available?<br>		37. Is ecoDnomic analysis available?<br>
	~~1pt~~ - ''TBD''		0pt - ''TBD''

	38. Is ergonomic analysis available?<br>		38. Is ergonomic analysis available?<br>
	~~1pt~~ - ''TBD''		0pt - ''TBD''

	===Bill of Materials (BOM)===		===Bill of Materials (BOM)===

Mjn at 18:06, 19 May 2011

2011-05-19T18:06:53Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:06, 19 May 2011
Line 40:		Line 40:

	11. Does it have Long Life?<br>		11. Does it have Long Life?<br>
	0pt - ''TBD'		0pt - ''TBD It is designed so that worn or broken parts can be replaced.'

	12. Is it modular?<br>		12. Is it modular?<br>
Line 56:		Line 56:

	16. Is it easily scalable?<br>		16. Is it easily scalable?<br>
			1pt - ''Yes. Add cylinders, modify the crankshaft and go.''

	==Localization==		==Localization==
	===Materials===		===Materials===
	17. Are materials used in production local?<br>		17. Are materials used in production local?<br>
			.5pt -''Some materials can be sourced locally, others will come from distance sources.''

	18. Is raw material production local?<br>		18. Is raw material production local?<br>
			0pt - ''No, not at this time.''

	===Production===		===Production===
	19. Is product production local?<br>		19. Is product production local?<br>
			0pt - ''Since it is not in production yet, no.''

	20. Is the machinery used in production process open source?<br>		20. Is the machinery used in production process open source?<br>
			1pt - ''Yes, OS lathe, milling, drilling.''

	21. Is the machinery used in production process locally fabricated?<br>		21. Is the machinery used in production process locally fabricated?<br>
			0pt - ''Not at this time, no. RepLab is still being produced.''

	==Economic Feasibility and Replicability==		==Economic Feasibility and Replicability==
	22. Is there minimal overhead?<br>		22. Is there minimal overhead?<br>
			1pt - ''Almost none, assuming a source of steam from a solar concentrator or biomass boiler. Some oil lubrication is needed.''

	23. Is there minimal waste?<br>		23. Is there minimal waste?<br>
			.5pt - ''By itself, the steam engine is wasteful - steam is vented as waste. Later, this could be re-used in other systems.''

	24. Are R&D costs shared by a number of stakeholders?<br>		24. Are R&D costs shared by a number of stakeholders?<br>
			0pt - ''Not really. There are very few stakeholders participating at this time.''

	25. Are services given away? <br>		25. Are services given away? <br>
			0pt - ''Not yet.''

	26. Are production facilities Crowd-funded?<br>		26. Are production facilities Crowd-funded?<br>
			0pt - ''Not yet.''

	==Product Evolution==		==Product Evolution==

	27. Is there continual produce maintenance? <br>		27. Is there continual produce maintenance? <br>
			0pt = ''TBD''

	28. Is there continual product development?<br>		28. Is there continual product development?<br>
			0pt = ''TBD''

	==Fabrication Facilities==		==Fabrication Facilities==

	29. Is there a flexible fabrication mechanism? <br>		29. Is there a flexible fabrication mechanism? <br>
			0pt = ''TBD''

	==Open Business Model==		==Open Business Model==

	30. Is there a Business Plan?<br>		30. Is there a Business Plan?<br>
			0pt - ''No business plan at this time.''

	31. Are there technical details in the business plan?<br>		31. Are there technical details in the business plan?<br>
			0pt - ''No business plan at this time.''

	==Open Documentation==		==Open Documentation==

	32. Is content Open Source?<br>		32. Is content Open Source?<br>
			1pt = ''Yes, see [[Steam Engine/Index]]''

	33. Is content readily accessible (downloadable)?<br>		33. Is content readily accessible (downloadable)?<br>
			.5 - ''Wiki pages only, at this time.''

	34. Are there design drawings?<br>		34. Are there design drawings?<br>
			1pt = ''Yes, many.''

	===Designs===		===Designs===
	35. Are design drawings CAD?<br>		35. Are design drawings CAD?<br>
			0pt = ''No, TBd''

	36. Are fabrication procedures detailed?<br>		36. Are fabrication procedures detailed?<br>
	37. Is ~~economic~~ analysis available?<br>		0.5pt - ''Fabrication details are in progress.''

			37. Is ecoDnomic analysis available?<br>
			1pt - ''TBD''

	38. Is ergonomic analysis available?<br>		38. Is ergonomic analysis available?<br>
			1pt - ''TBD''

	===Bill of Materials (BOM)===		===Bill of Materials (BOM)===
	39. Is there a parts list?<br>		39. Is there a parts list?<br>
			1pt - ''Yes, see [[Steam Engine Bill of Materials]]''

	40. Is Sourcing of parts listed?<br>		40. Is Sourcing of parts listed?<br>
			1pt - ''Yes, see [[Steam Engine Bill of Materials]]''

	41. Are prices of parts listed?<br>		41. Are prices of parts listed?<br>
			0.5 - ''Some, see [[Steam Engine Bill of Materials]]''

	==Start-up Assistance==		==Start-up Assistance==

	42. Is producer training available?<br>		42. Is producer training available?<br>
			0pt - ''TBD''

	=Metric Roll-up and Score=		=Metric Roll-up and Score=

			{\|
			\|-

			\|-
			\|}

Mjn at 17:31, 19 May 2011

2011-05-19T17:31:41Z

Show changes