Revision as of 19:50, 29 August 2007

This page was tagged as a candidate for deletion. If this page does not meet our criteria for deletion, please remove this notice.

(Explanation: deprecated, use Template: Under construction instead)

This page is a draft.
There may be relevant discussion on the talk page

Notes on Wiki Infrastructure for Open Engineering

Marcin's comments:

We need: a Platform for Open Engineering
Marcin's personal attempt: openfarmtech.org - under Development Template.
- However, this has a particular spec for its open engineering - it it open engineering + OSE Specifications (see Main Page)
Once a better infrastructure for projects exists at Appropedia, then we could consider using it for some technical developments.
Summary: unless someone can show me a better development platform, the Development Template is good enough for now. It embodies OSE Spec.

Critical additional comment:

OSE adds value in that (1) attempts open engineering, (2) does so according to a very unique goal - replicable villages with particular attributes as described on the Main Page
It is the addition of value according to a unique goal that adds value to the open engineering itself. It is what drives the specifications for open engineering.
I don't think one would come up with an option for creating OSE's replicable village if one just took a number of technologies and put them together. The OSE Specification (look on Main Page) is a glue for the type of engineering that goes on. Without that glue, you'd never arrive at the type of engineering proposed.

Comments?

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 =Notes on Wiki Infrastructure for Open Engineering=
-Mel's Comment:
-Marcin and I just spoke about this on the phone - Marcin, reminderping
-to coordinate a discussion w/ Chris (cc'd) & Vinay on the wiki-merge issue.
-The way I see it, Appropedia can become a Sourceforge for open
-engineering. (Sure, it could use a better infrastructure for projects,
-but... we can work on that.)* It's a place where individual open
-engineering projects related to appropriate technology can have project
-websites, host files, etc. Development work, instructions on how to
-build a hexayurt, etc. would all be here.
-OSE can then go and say things like "Look at all these different pieces
-of the puzzle that exist - full-fledged technologies being developed
-independently on places like Appropedia. Here's how you could combine
-them all into a working village - for housing, you could build hexayurts
-like this <link to hexayurt-building instruction pages on Appropedia>
-which would mean X, Y, and Z for the economics/dynamics/environmental
-impact of the village."
-But that's just my $0.02, and I'll leave the discussion to Marcin,
-Vinay, and Chris.
--Mel
-----
 Marcin's comments: