CEB Vaults: Difference between revisions
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Timbrel Vaults == | == Timbrel Vaults == | ||
(hat tip: Abe Connally) Brick, stone and concrete are materials strong in compression but weak in tension. Nowadays, this problem is solved by steel structures or the use of steel-reinforced concrete (the tensile strength of steel is significantly more than that of bricks, stone or plain concrete). Pre World War II, the weak tensile strength of brick was compensated for by superior craftsmanship. The '''timbrel vault''' technique was cheap, fast, ecological and durable. These structures are similar in appearance to ferrocement but rely on entirely different materials and technique. Basically, a vault is built using tiles, and this requires very little formwork. The tiles then become the form for the roof. | (hat tip: Abe Connally) Brick, stone and concrete are materials strong in compression but weak in tension. Nowadays, this problem is solved by steel structures or the use of steel-reinforced concrete (the tensile strength of steel is significantly more than that of bricks, stone or plain concrete). Pre World War II, the weak tensile strength of brick was compensated for by superior craftsmanship. The '''timbrel vault''' technique was cheap, fast, ecological and durable. These structures are similar in appearance to ferrocement but rely on entirely different materials and technique. Basically, a vault is built using tiles, and this requires very little formwork. The tiles then become the form for the roof. This technique was brought to the United States by the Guastavino family from catalonia. | ||
[[File:Ellis_island_reception_hall.jpg]] | [[File:Ellis_island_reception_hall.jpg]] | ||
Relevant links: | Relevant links: | ||
*highly recommended: [http://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2008/11/tiles-vaults.html Tiles as a substitute for steel: the art of the timbrel vault (Low-Tech Magazine)] | |||
*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guastavino_tile | *http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guastavino_tile | ||
*http://www.guastavino.net/ | *http://www.guastavino.net/ | ||
*http://crossway.tumblr.com/ | *http://crossway.tumblr.com/ | ||
Revision as of 20:26, 1 January 2011
Timbrel Vaults
(hat tip: Abe Connally) Brick, stone and concrete are materials strong in compression but weak in tension. Nowadays, this problem is solved by steel structures or the use of steel-reinforced concrete (the tensile strength of steel is significantly more than that of bricks, stone or plain concrete). Pre World War II, the weak tensile strength of brick was compensated for by superior craftsmanship. The timbrel vault technique was cheap, fast, ecological and durable. These structures are similar in appearance to ferrocement but rely on entirely different materials and technique. Basically, a vault is built using tiles, and this requires very little formwork. The tiles then become the form for the roof. This technique was brought to the United States by the Guastavino family from catalonia.
Relevant links:
- highly recommended: Tiles as a substitute for steel: the art of the timbrel vault (Low-Tech Magazine)
- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guastavino_tile
- http://www.guastavino.net/
- http://crossway.tumblr.com/
Comments
(from Rasmus) There is almost no experience with using compressed earth tiles ("CETs"?) in Guastavino-type masonry. The unresolved question is whether CETs will deliver adequate structural performance, similar to fired tiles. This should be addressed by performing side-by-side comparisons of fired tiles vs. compressed earth tiles. One example where pressed tiles were used is the Mapungubwe National Park Interpretive Centre in South Africa, which won the Holcim Awards in 2008. Many technical details about the construction process can be found in this manual. Page 18 of the manual shows photos of tile production for that project:
More comments:
- In Sept. 2010, John Ochsendorf (MIT) published a book: "Guastavino Vaulting: The Art of Structural Tile[1]"
- An alternative option to pressed tiles would be to use geopolymer tiles, which would require a relatively low (~450°C) kiln temperature and may have structural properties similar to regular fired tiles. But that's really terra incognita.
- When building larger communities, the possibility of building standardized components should be considered, such as ceilings and window frames. These can be mass-produced and then transported to the construction site. This would bring down cost and increase workplace safety.