Open Source Cordless Drill Industry Standards: Difference between revisions

From Open Source Ecology
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Added some more information)
(Added some more information)
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 15: Line 15:


=Internal Links=
=Internal Links=
*
*Channels that do High Quality Tests + Reviews of Power Tools:
**[[TorqueTestChannel (YouTube Channel) ]]
***Originally just did [[Impact Wrench]] tests (hence the name), but have recently forked out to other devices as well
**[[Project Farm (YouTube Channel) ]]
***While sometimes not PERFECTLY scientific, they make up for it in thoroughness/lack of sponsorship bias
****Also their latest videos have benefitted from more funds for proper sensors etc
**[[VCG Construction (YouTube Channel) ]]
***The occasional clickbaity title, but their tests are good, and they also have some of the PROFESSIONAL “long term use” type reviews/know how, which can be of use
****IE tool works great on a test bench, but too heavy/not ergonomic in the field, or something that SEEMS niche but actually is helpful when you need it etc


=External Links=
=External Links=
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LroQPn59bWg A Video by the YouTube Channel “Diodes Gone Wild” Titled “ inside a cordless drill (with schematic & gearbox autopsy)” ] ( ‘’’About ~16 Minute Watch’’’ )
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LroQPn59bWg A Video by the YouTube Channel “Diodes Gone Wild” Titled “ inside a cordless drill (with schematic & gearbox autopsy)” ] ( ‘’’About ~16 Minute Watch’’’ )
**The video shows the insides of a cordless drill
**The video shows the insides of a cordless drill
*[https://youtu.be/hDofGQMYIFI?si=F00W7Ol11cpPPrwn A Video by the YouTube Channel “TorqueTestChannel” Titled “Cordless Drills: Is Buying Top Models Even Worth It These Days?” ]
**2024 Video/Models
**Compares “Best of the Best” vs Chinese White Label off Amazon etc
**Uses an [[Automotive Disc Brake Derived Dynamometer]] for torque measurement which is novel
**Also a [[DC Programmable Electric Load]] for [[Load Testing]]
*[https://youtu.be/r68Wmf-aoDw?si=w_cgf-H2udIMqs3j A Video by the YouTube Channel “TorqueTestChannel” Titled “How to: Buy Amazon Cordless Tools that Don’t Suck” ] ( ‘’’~18 Minute Watch’’’ )
**Main Points:
***#1 Check Local Sales First on Name Brand
***#2 Use Amazon or Assume Liability that it may not be legit etc
****Although if using a trusted vendor disregard
****Also valid point on [[Enshitification]] of Amazon
***#3 Dewalt Mid-torque Size or Larger / Some Fundinental Size Constraints for a “good” tool
***#4 [[Brushless Motors]] not [[Brushed Motors]] (Aka [[BLDC]] )
***#5 Focus on other data sources than the website/algorithm/[[Review Literacy]]
***#6 Share a Common Battery Platform (Most use [[Makita LXT]] supposedly?)
****Although an [[Open Source Cordless Power Tool Translator Adapter]] could fix this
*****IE not just a dumb Pin+Wire Adapter, but makes voltages compatible and shares data
***#7 Look out for [[White Label Designs]] and if so go with whatever is cheapest (all else being equal)
***#8 Advertised Torque (and many other specs) can be lies
***#9 Non-Your Local Market Tool Brands are a thing, and may carry a similar or better level of Quality/Trust ([[ESG]] Stuff Notwithstanding)
***# Look for reviews / let others (professional reviewers etc) try risky options out

Latest revision as of 18:19, 6 January 2026

Basics

Thoughts by User: Eric

  • For the most part (at least here in the North American market) :
    • Ryobi is a good budget option, that is getting a BIT into the Pro-Sumer Market
    • Dewalt and Milwaukee Tool are the best of the best, and while one may top the other in terms lf the spec depending on the year, both are great options
      • One thing to note is that if going for that preformance though, be sure to get their “pro” models such as the “Milwaukee Fuel” linup, or the “Dewalt XR” lineup
        • When in doubt, check the model number
        • ESPECIALLY combo deals/sales at home depot and whatnot they sometimes try and get sneaky on you
    • Battery Versions/Performance is another thing
      • Some batteries have more Specific Power than others, and despite the standard “matching”, some tools need a high Amp capable battery and will lock up on smaller batteries
        • Inversely, some smaller tools cannot fit larger batteries past hand grips or dust bags etc

Internal Links

  • Channels that do High Quality Tests + Reviews of Power Tools:
    • TorqueTestChannel (YouTube Channel)
      • Originally just did Impact Wrench tests (hence the name), but have recently forked out to other devices as well
    • Project Farm (YouTube Channel)
      • While sometimes not PERFECTLY scientific, they make up for it in thoroughness/lack of sponsorship bias
        • Also their latest videos have benefitted from more funds for proper sensors etc
    • VCG Construction (YouTube Channel)
      • The occasional clickbaity title, but their tests are good, and they also have some of the PROFESSIONAL “long term use” type reviews/know how, which can be of use
        • IE tool works great on a test bench, but too heavy/not ergonomic in the field, or something that SEEMS niche but actually is helpful when you need it etc

External Links