Curriculum Development Methods: Difference between revisions

From Open Source Ecology
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "Backward design, competency-based, mastery, project-based, and other - https://chatgpt.com/share/69a52df8-9648-8010-b7c0-30784ed1362b")
 
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Backward design, competency-based, mastery, project-based, and other - https://chatgpt.com/share/69a52df8-9648-8010-b7c0-30784ed1362b
Spiral curriculum, backward design, competency-based, mastery, project-based, and other - https://chatgpt.com/share/69a52df8-9648-8010-b7c0-30784ed1362b
 
{| class="wikitable sortable"
! Rank
! Pedagogy
! Key Theorist / Origin
! Core Principle
! Relevance to OSE (1–5)
! OSE Example
|-
| 1
| Mastery Learning
| Benjamin Bloom
| Learners must demonstrate high-level competence before progressing.
| 5
| Apprentices must demonstrate precise mark–measure–cut accuracy before participating in structural framing.
|-
| 2
| Competency-Based Education (CBE)
| Workforce & technical education model
| Progression based on demonstrated competencies rather than seat time.
| 5
| Certification ladder: welding level 1 → 2 → structural welder before contributing to tractor chassis fabrication.
|-
| 3
| Project-Based Learning (PBL)
| Buck Institute (PBLWorks)
| Curriculum organized around authentic, real-world projects.
| 5
| 6-week Seed Eco-Home build serving as the primary learning vehicle.
|-
| 4
| Experiential Learning Cycle
| David Kolb
| Learn through build → reflect → abstract → test iteration.
| 5
| After installing a hydraulic system, team conducts structured retrospective and redesign improvements.
|-
| 5
| Systems Instructional Design (ADDIE)
| Military / corporate training
| Structured process: Analyze → Design → Develop → Implement → Evaluate.
| 4
| Designing a repeatable 12-week Bootcamp curriculum across multiple campuses.
|-
| 6
| Dick & Carey Systems Model
| Walter Dick & Lou Carey
| Instruction designed as an interlocking performance system with task analysis.
| 4
| Breaking down induction furnace build into discrete performance objectives and verification checkpoints.
|-
| 7
| Spiral Curriculum
| Jerome Bruner
| Concepts revisited at increasing levels of sophistication.
| 4
| First learn basic MIG welding → later structural welding → later robotic welding integration.
|-
| 8
| Problem-Based Learning
| McMaster University (medical model)
| Students confront a complex problem before receiving instruction.
| 4
| Diagnose why a hydraulic motor stalls under load without step-by-step instructions.
|-
| 9
| Integrated / Interdisciplinary Curriculum
| Progressive education movement
| Organizes learning around systems rather than disciplines.
| 4
| Tractor build integrates CAD, hydraulics, metallurgy, budgeting, and team coordination.
|-
| 10
| Backward Design (Understanding by Design)
| Grant Wiggins & Jay McTighe
| Start with desired outcomes and work backward to assessments and activities.
| 3
| Define “competent open-source builder” outcomes before designing build exercises.
|-
| 11
| Taba Inductive Model
| Hilda Taba
| Teachers design curriculum bottom-up from diagnosed needs.
| 3
| Local campus modifies build sequence based on participant readiness and shop constraints.
|-
| 12
| Tyler Rationale
| Ralph Tyler
| Curriculum organized around behavioral objectives.
| 2
| Safety training with explicit measurable objectives for tool handling compliance.
|-
| 13
| Montessori Model
| Maria Montessori
| Self-directed learning within a prepared environment.
| 2
| Rapid Learning Facility with tool stations allowing autonomous repetition of skills.
|-
| 14
| Reggio Emilia Approach
| Reggio Emilia, Italy
| Emergent curriculum driven by learner inquiry and documentation.
| 2
| Public documentation boards tracking design evolution of open-source machines.
|-
| 15
| Waldorf Curriculum
| Rudolf Steiner
| Holistic, developmental, arts-integrated learning.
| 1
| Limited relevance beyond cultural formation and narrative framing.
|-
| 16
| Core Knowledge Sequence
| E.D. Hirsch Jr.
| Structured shared cultural content canon.
| 1
| Background systems literacy modules (history of industrialization), not central to build process.
|}

Revision as of 06:37, 2 March 2026

Spiral curriculum, backward design, competency-based, mastery, project-based, and other - https://chatgpt.com/share/69a52df8-9648-8010-b7c0-30784ed1362b

Rank Pedagogy Key Theorist / Origin Core Principle Relevance to OSE (1–5) OSE Example
1 Mastery Learning Benjamin Bloom Learners must demonstrate high-level competence before progressing. 5 Apprentices must demonstrate precise mark–measure–cut accuracy before participating in structural framing.
2 Competency-Based Education (CBE) Workforce & technical education model Progression based on demonstrated competencies rather than seat time. 5 Certification ladder: welding level 1 → 2 → structural welder before contributing to tractor chassis fabrication.
3 Project-Based Learning (PBL) Buck Institute (PBLWorks) Curriculum organized around authentic, real-world projects. 5 6-week Seed Eco-Home build serving as the primary learning vehicle.
4 Experiential Learning Cycle David Kolb Learn through build → reflect → abstract → test iteration. 5 After installing a hydraulic system, team conducts structured retrospective and redesign improvements.
5 Systems Instructional Design (ADDIE) Military / corporate training Structured process: Analyze → Design → Develop → Implement → Evaluate. 4 Designing a repeatable 12-week Bootcamp curriculum across multiple campuses.
6 Dick & Carey Systems Model Walter Dick & Lou Carey Instruction designed as an interlocking performance system with task analysis. 4 Breaking down induction furnace build into discrete performance objectives and verification checkpoints.
7 Spiral Curriculum Jerome Bruner Concepts revisited at increasing levels of sophistication. 4 First learn basic MIG welding → later structural welding → later robotic welding integration.
8 Problem-Based Learning McMaster University (medical model) Students confront a complex problem before receiving instruction. 4 Diagnose why a hydraulic motor stalls under load without step-by-step instructions.
9 Integrated / Interdisciplinary Curriculum Progressive education movement Organizes learning around systems rather than disciplines. 4 Tractor build integrates CAD, hydraulics, metallurgy, budgeting, and team coordination.
10 Backward Design (Understanding by Design) Grant Wiggins & Jay McTighe Start with desired outcomes and work backward to assessments and activities. 3 Define “competent open-source builder” outcomes before designing build exercises.
11 Taba Inductive Model Hilda Taba Teachers design curriculum bottom-up from diagnosed needs. 3 Local campus modifies build sequence based on participant readiness and shop constraints.
12 Tyler Rationale Ralph Tyler Curriculum organized around behavioral objectives. 2 Safety training with explicit measurable objectives for tool handling compliance.
13 Montessori Model Maria Montessori Self-directed learning within a prepared environment. 2 Rapid Learning Facility with tool stations allowing autonomous repetition of skills.
14 Reggio Emilia Approach Reggio Emilia, Italy Emergent curriculum driven by learner inquiry and documentation. 2 Public documentation boards tracking design evolution of open-source machines.
15 Waldorf Curriculum Rudolf Steiner Holistic, developmental, arts-integrated learning. 1 Limited relevance beyond cultural formation and narrative framing.
16 Core Knowledge Sequence E.D. Hirsch Jr. Structured shared cultural content canon. 1 Background systems literacy modules (history of industrialization), not central to build process.