Laminated Ferrocement: Difference between revisions

From Open Source Ecology
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "LFC")
 
No edit summary
 
(10 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
LFC
LFC
'''LFC Tests on panels'''
6-13-2011 by Abe Connally, [http://www.velacreations.com]
'''Panel 1''' - 1 layer 3/8" hardware cloth, 36.5" X 20.75" - 757 si, 5.26 sf
* 5/16" - 3/8" thick
* Cured for 3 days
* 17lbs, 3.23 lbs/sf
'''Panel 2''' - 2 layers 3/8" hardware cloth, 36.5" X 20.375" - 744 si, 5.17 sf
* 3/8" - 7/16" thick
* Cured for 3 days
* 22lbs, 4.25 lbs/sf
'''Tests''' - panels were placed on bricks, spaced 14" apart.  Weight was placed in center of panel, between brick supports.
* Test 1 - 1 gallon water @ 8lbs on 2.25 si, 3.55 psi
* Test 2 - 1 gallon water @ 8lbs on 1.5 si, 5.33 psi
* Test 3 - human @ 173 lbs on 46 si, 3.76 psi
'''Results'''
* Test 1, panel 1  - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
* Test 1, panel 2  - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
* Test 2, panel 1  - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
* Test 2, panel 2  - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
* Test 3, panel 1  - troweled side down - visible sag but no cracks
* Test 3, panel 2  - troweled side down - slight visible sag but no cracks
* Test 3, panel 1  - troweled side up - extreme sag and panel snapped along brick support
* Test 3, panel 2  - troweled side up - visible sag but no cracks
Troweled side has 1/8" less concrete on mesh
'''Conclusions'''
Both panels survived psi ratings for tank design (3.44 psi), however because troweled side has less concrete, it is a weaker side of panel in compression.  Suggest using formed side as inside of tank, so that the troweled side will be in greater tension (more mesh, less concrete). 
Panel 2 with 2 layers of mesh seem to be stronger in all tests.
I think these would do just fine as roof tiles or panels, especially if shaped to take advantage of concrete's compression strength.  For a water tank, although they survived the psi required for an 8ft tall tank, I think more testing is required.
'''More Information'''
* [[:File:Ferrocement_panels_-_water_tank.pdf|LFC Panel Water Tank]]
* [[:File:Ferrocement channels.pdf|LFC Channel Roof]]
[[Category: Housing and construction]]

Latest revision as of 22:08, 13 June 2011

LFC


LFC Tests on panels

6-13-2011 by Abe Connally, [1]


Panel 1 - 1 layer 3/8" hardware cloth, 36.5" X 20.75" - 757 si, 5.26 sf

  • 5/16" - 3/8" thick
  • Cured for 3 days
  • 17lbs, 3.23 lbs/sf


Panel 2 - 2 layers 3/8" hardware cloth, 36.5" X 20.375" - 744 si, 5.17 sf

  • 3/8" - 7/16" thick
  • Cured for 3 days
  • 22lbs, 4.25 lbs/sf


Tests - panels were placed on bricks, spaced 14" apart. Weight was placed in center of panel, between brick supports.

  • Test 1 - 1 gallon water @ 8lbs on 2.25 si, 3.55 psi
  • Test 2 - 1 gallon water @ 8lbs on 1.5 si, 5.33 psi
  • Test 3 - human @ 173 lbs on 46 si, 3.76 psi


Results

  • Test 1, panel 1 - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
  • Test 1, panel 2 - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
  • Test 2, panel 1 - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
  • Test 2, panel 2 - troweled side up - no visible sag or cracks
  • Test 3, panel 1 - troweled side down - visible sag but no cracks
  • Test 3, panel 2 - troweled side down - slight visible sag but no cracks
  • Test 3, panel 1 - troweled side up - extreme sag and panel snapped along brick support
  • Test 3, panel 2 - troweled side up - visible sag but no cracks

Troweled side has 1/8" less concrete on mesh


Conclusions

Both panels survived psi ratings for tank design (3.44 psi), however because troweled side has less concrete, it is a weaker side of panel in compression. Suggest using formed side as inside of tank, so that the troweled side will be in greater tension (more mesh, less concrete). Panel 2 with 2 layers of mesh seem to be stronger in all tests.

I think these would do just fine as roof tiles or panels, especially if shaped to take advantage of concrete's compression strength. For a water tank, although they survived the psi required for an 8ft tall tank, I think more testing is required.


More Information