Open Source Cordless Drill Industry Standards: Difference between revisions

From Open Source Ecology
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "*https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LroQPn59bWg - insides of a cordless drill")
 
(Added some more information)
 
(9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
*https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LroQPn59bWg - insides of a cordless drill
=Basics=
*This page aims to organize+investigate the current Industry Standards in terms of Cordless Drills
**[[Impact Drivers]] ,  [[Hammerdrills]] and [[Rotary Hammerdrills]] / [[SDS Drills]] are somewhat related as well
 
=Thoughts by User: Eric=
*For the most part (at least here in the North American market) :
**Ryobi is a good budget option, that is getting a BIT into the [[Pro-Sumer]] Market
**[[Dewalt]] and [[Milwaukee Tool]] are the best of the best, and while one may top the other in terms lf the spec depending on the year, both are great options
***One thing to note is that if going for that preformance though, be sure to get their “pro” models such as the “Milwaukee Fuel” linup, or the “Dewalt XR” lineup
****When in doubt, check the model number
****ESPECIALLY combo deals/sales at home depot and whatnot they sometimes try and get sneaky on you
**Battery Versions/Performance is another thing
***Some batteries have more [[Specific Power]] than others, and despite the standard “matching”, some tools need a high Amp capable battery and will lock up on smaller batteries
****Inversely, some smaller tools cannot fit larger batteries past hand grips or dust bags etc
 
=Internal Links=
*Channels that do High Quality Tests + Reviews of Power Tools:
**[[TorqueTestChannel (YouTube Channel) ]]
***Originally just did [[Impact Wrench]] tests (hence the name), but have recently forked out to other devices as well
**[[Project Farm (YouTube Channel) ]]
***While sometimes not PERFECTLY scientific, they make up for it in thoroughness/lack of sponsorship bias
****Also their latest videos have benefitted from more funds for proper sensors etc
**[[VCG Construction (YouTube Channel) ]]
***The occasional clickbaity title, but their tests are good, and they also have some of the PROFESSIONAL “long term use” type reviews/know how, which can be of use
****IE tool works great on a test bench, but too heavy/not ergonomic in the field, or something that SEEMS niche but actually is helpful when you need it etc
 
=External Links=
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LroQPn59bWg A Video by the YouTube Channel “Diodes Gone Wild” Titled “ inside a cordless drill (with schematic & gearbox autopsy)” ] ( ‘’’About ~16 Minute Watch’’’ )
**The video shows the insides of a cordless drill
*[https://youtu.be/hDofGQMYIFI?si=F00W7Ol11cpPPrwn A Video by the YouTube Channel “TorqueTestChannel” Titled “Cordless Drills: Is Buying Top Models Even Worth It These Days?” ]
**2024 Video/Models
**Compares “Best of the Best” vs Chinese White Label off Amazon etc
**Uses an [[Automotive Disc Brake Derived Dynamometer]] for torque measurement which is novel
**Also a [[DC Programmable Electric Load]] for [[Load Testing]]
*[https://youtu.be/r68Wmf-aoDw?si=w_cgf-H2udIMqs3j A Video by the YouTube Channel “TorqueTestChannel” Titled “How to: Buy Amazon Cordless Tools that Don’t Suck” ] ( ‘’’~18 Minute Watch’’’ )
**Main Points:
***#1 Check Local Sales First on Name Brand
***#2 Use Amazon or Assume Liability that it may not be legit etc
****Although if using a trusted vendor disregard
****Also valid point on [[Enshitification]] of Amazon
***#3 Dewalt Mid-torque Size or Larger / Some Fundinental Size Constraints for a “good” tool
***#4 [[Brushless Motors]] not [[Brushed Motors]] (Aka [[BLDC]] )
***#5 Focus on other data sources than the website/algorithm/[[Review Literacy]]
***#6 Share a Common Battery Platform (Most use [[Makita LXT]] supposedly?)
****Although an [[Open Source Cordless Power Tool Translator Adapter]] could fix this
*****IE not just a dumb Pin+Wire Adapter, but makes voltages compatible and shares data
***#7 Look out for [[White Label Designs]] and if so go with whatever is cheapest (all else being equal)
***#8 Advertised Torque (and many other specs) can be lies
***#9 Non-Your Local Market Tool Brands are a thing, and may carry a similar or better level of Quality/Trust ([[ESG]] Stuff Notwithstanding)
***# Look for reviews / let others (professional reviewers etc) try risky options out

Latest revision as of 18:19, 6 January 2026

Basics

Thoughts by User: Eric

  • For the most part (at least here in the North American market) :
    • Ryobi is a good budget option, that is getting a BIT into the Pro-Sumer Market
    • Dewalt and Milwaukee Tool are the best of the best, and while one may top the other in terms lf the spec depending on the year, both are great options
      • One thing to note is that if going for that preformance though, be sure to get their “pro” models such as the “Milwaukee Fuel” linup, or the “Dewalt XR” lineup
        • When in doubt, check the model number
        • ESPECIALLY combo deals/sales at home depot and whatnot they sometimes try and get sneaky on you
    • Battery Versions/Performance is another thing
      • Some batteries have more Specific Power than others, and despite the standard “matching”, some tools need a high Amp capable battery and will lock up on smaller batteries
        • Inversely, some smaller tools cannot fit larger batteries past hand grips or dust bags etc

Internal Links

  • Channels that do High Quality Tests + Reviews of Power Tools:
    • TorqueTestChannel (YouTube Channel)
      • Originally just did Impact Wrench tests (hence the name), but have recently forked out to other devices as well
    • Project Farm (YouTube Channel)
      • While sometimes not PERFECTLY scientific, they make up for it in thoroughness/lack of sponsorship bias
        • Also their latest videos have benefitted from more funds for proper sensors etc
    • VCG Construction (YouTube Channel)
      • The occasional clickbaity title, but their tests are good, and they also have some of the PROFESSIONAL “long term use” type reviews/know how, which can be of use
        • IE tool works great on a test bench, but too heavy/not ergonomic in the field, or something that SEEMS niche but actually is helpful when you need it etc

External Links