Hydrogen Production: Difference between revisions

From Open Source Ecology
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 11: Line 11:
*$3.33/kg cost for power plant storage - [https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2014/03/f10/46719.pdf]
*$3.33/kg cost for power plant storage - [https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2014/03/f10/46719.pdf]
*From steam reforming of methane - $1.25/kg - [https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/hydrogen-production-cost#:~:text=Hydrogen%20Production%20and%20Current%20Technologies&text=For%20instance%2C%20the%20hydrogen%20production,of%200.3%20US%24%2Fkg.]
*From steam reforming of methane - $1.25/kg - [https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/hydrogen-production-cost#:~:text=Hydrogen%20Production%20and%20Current%20Technologies&text=For%20instance%2C%20the%20hydrogen%20production,of%200.3%20US%24%2Fkg.]
*Extreme case - Based on [[Seed Eco-Home PV System]], we go with 50 cent/kW cost of panels with large shipping orders (40 cents for a contaner - in which container shipping is $500, compared to full trailer load. Then we reduce system cost 30% by feeding electrolyzers directly instead of using inverters, chargers, and storage. Then we go from 2 cents to 1.4 cents - to 1 cent by 40 year lifetime instead of 25 year lifetime of panels. So we go down to 66 cents per GGE.
*'''Extreme existing cost reduction case''' - Based on [[Seed Eco-Home PV System]], we go with 50 cent/kW cost of panels with large shipping orders (40 cents for a contaner - in which container shipping is $500, compared to full trailer load). Then we reduce system cost 30% by feeding electrolyzers directly instead of using inverters, chargers, and storage. Then we go from 2 cents to 1.4 cents with this 30% reduction - to 1 cent by 40 year lifetime instead of 25 year lifetime of panels. So we go down to 66 cents per GGE.
*Paper showing $5/kg production, at 1000 kg/day scale. Most of the cost is electricity. [https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy09osti/44103.pdf]. Assumes 5c/kwhr cost. Thus, right there we have <$2.5/kg cost of hydrogen if electricity cost were negligible compared to 5c/kwhr.
*Paper showing $5/kg production, at 1000 kg/day scale. Most of the cost is electricity. [https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy09osti/44103.pdf]. Assumes 5c/kwhr cost. Thus, right there we have <$2.5/kg cost of hydrogen if electricity cost were negligible compared to 5c/kwhr.
*$3.2Euro/kg - [https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2017.00001/full]
*$3.2Euro/kg - [https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2017.00001/full]
*Capital costs of $1k/kw_e cost for 1kW electric input- [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360319917339435]
*Capital costs of $1k/kw_e cost for 1kW electric input- [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360319917339435]
*Electrolyzer is $1k/kw and 75000 hours life for alkaline electrolyzers - [https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/final_icct2020_assessment_of%20_hydrogen_production_costs%20v2.pdf]
*Electrolyzer is $1k/kw and 75000 hours life for alkaline electrolyzers - [https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/final_icct2020_assessment_of%20_hydrogen_production_costs%20v2.pdf]
**Capital costs of generation: 66 hours per kg equivalent. Electrolyzer can make 1000 gallons of gasoline - per $1000. So capital costs are $1 per gallon. This reflects the industry, where capex of electrolyzer is comparable to electricity costs of producing hydrogen.


=Research=
=Research=

Revision as of 22:54, 12 August 2020

Basics

  • This page explores various methods of hydrogen production
  • 39.4 kWh of electricity and 8.9 liters (l) of water at normal conditions (25 C and 1 atm) to make 1 kg of hydrogen [1]
  • Electrolyzers (alkaline and PEM) are 50-80% efficient [2]

Cost

  • This article states that hydrogen cannot be produced cheaply. [3] However, if we use OSE's 1 cent/kWhr cost of electricity as documented in the Seed Eco-Home PV System, with alkaline electrolyzers (see Hydrogen Production, the cost of returning that electricity through solar hydrogen is 5 cents per kWhr. See Round-Trip Electricity from Hydrogen.
  • Alkaline electrolyzer generation cost is -
  • Hydrogen applience - $7.60/kg hydrogen - [4]
  • Hydrogen generator - 6kWhr/cu m. 1 cu m is 45 moles, or 90 grams of hydrogen. [5] This system would thus cost 12 cents (conservative) per 90 grams using the OSE PV system. This is $1.32/kg of hydrogen. The GGE is thus $1.32/gallon equivalent cost of gasoline. The 6kWhr/cu m is reasonable, in that it reflects a 66 kWhr cost of electricity per kg of hydrogen - the standard value for an alkaline electrolyzer implying 60% efficiency.
  • $3.33/kg cost for power plant storage - [6]
  • From steam reforming of methane - $1.25/kg - [7]
  • Extreme existing cost reduction case - Based on Seed Eco-Home PV System, we go with 50 cent/kW cost of panels with large shipping orders (40 cents for a contaner - in which container shipping is $500, compared to full trailer load). Then we reduce system cost 30% by feeding electrolyzers directly instead of using inverters, chargers, and storage. Then we go from 2 cents to 1.4 cents with this 30% reduction - to 1 cent by 40 year lifetime instead of 25 year lifetime of panels. So we go down to 66 cents per GGE.
  • Paper showing $5/kg production, at 1000 kg/day scale. Most of the cost is electricity. [8]. Assumes 5c/kwhr cost. Thus, right there we have <$2.5/kg cost of hydrogen if electricity cost were negligible compared to 5c/kwhr.
  • $3.2Euro/kg - [9]
  • Capital costs of $1k/kw_e cost for 1kW electric input- [10]
  • Electrolyzer is $1k/kw and 75000 hours life for alkaline electrolyzers - [11]
    • Capital costs of generation: 66 hours per kg equivalent. Electrolyzer can make 1000 gallons of gasoline - per $1000. So capital costs are $1 per gallon. This reflects the industry, where capex of electrolyzer is comparable to electricity costs of producing hydrogen.

Research

Energy Requirements

  • about 50kWhr [12] to produce one kg of hydrogen. At electrical costs of 10 cents per kWhr, that is $5 per kilo, equivalent to a $5/gal of gasoline cost for the Energy Density.
  • For the Seed Eco-Home built in 2016 - the total installed marginal cost of 3kW is $2000 in 2017 - See Seed Eco-Home PV Cost. This could produce 1 kg of hydrogen in 3 days. Perfect. Annual cost of fuel at $3/gal is $1200 - 400 gallons at 25 mpg - for 10k average miles. So we would get free fuel after 2 years of use.
  • If cost over lifetime is considered - 20 years at 3kW of production yields 20*365*6*3 kWhrs = 131,400 kWhrs. This yields an energy cost of 1.5 cents per kilowatt hour. Or equivalent to 80 cent per gallon gasoline cost.
  • This makes a great case for the Seed Eco-Home + Hydrogen Filling Station + Open Source Hydrogen Car + Microfactory + Aquaponic Greenhouse as a productive unit for civilization with automated food harvest and passive electricity and fuels production.


Electrolysis Of Water

Wind Hydrogen

See $6k concept design of 20 kw wind turbine - Deka-kW_VAWT_Wind_Turbine. If the think lives for 20 years, and has a median capaity factor of 40% - [13] - then we are getting 5 kW of power for $6k. Compared to 3kW for $2k, but with 1/2 the capacity factor of wind - the solar option translates to 3kW for $4k compared to wind. Thus, the wind power option is approximately similar to PV. Except the wind can be self-manufactured, but probably has higher maintenance costs. However, if the wind turbine lasts 100 years, then we have a significant advantage. Further, if we could get a larger system than 20kW for wind - then we could be at an advantage in cost performance.

H from Aluminum

One way to generate hydrogen is by reacting aluminum with base such as NaOH.

This company promises $2000 home scale units for producing hydrogen at $1 per Kg

https://www.computerworld.com/article/3066072/sustainable-it/new-generator-can-halve-cost-of-hydrogen-used-to-power-buildings-cars.html

Steam Reforming of Hydrocarbons

  • This breaks down hydrocarbons into hydrogen and other byproducts (Usually carbon dioxide or carbon monoxide, althugh not always)
  • This is usually done with fossil fuels, but it could use renewable biofuels such as biodigester gas (either impure, or purified to pure methane)
  • Wikipedia Page on Steam Reforming

Artificial Photosynthesis (Also Called Photocatalytic Production)

Biohydrogen

  • This uses genetically modified microrganisms to produce hydrogen, either by modified photosynthesis, or by modified fermentation of sugar
  • Wikipedia Page on Biohydrogen

See Also